Since 2016, the podcast has used Patreon to fund production.
Initially, the monthly support tiers were as follows, with each tier including the benefits of lower tiers.
| Tier | Name | Benefits |
|---|---|---|
| $2.50 | Matt Albers Club | None |
| $5 | Ryan Webb Club | On-air thank-you |
| $10 | Ned Garver Club | Early access to episodes Live postseason game commentaries (2 per year) |
| $15 | Gonny Jomes Club | Email question priority on podcast Free access to Baseball Mogul |
| $30 | Rich Hill Club | Ad-Free Fangraphs membership Individual response to email questions |
| $50 | Barry Bonds Club | Signed copy of The Only Rule Is It Has to Work |
| $100 | Mike Trout Club | Guest appearance on episode |
On November 10, 2021, the podcast renamed its Patreon support tiers and added additional perks:
| Tier | Name | Benefits |
|---|---|---|
| $2.50 | Matt Albers Club | Access to Discord channel (new) |
| $5 | Willians Astudillo Club | On-air thank-you Access to Patreon Bonus Episodes (new) |
| $10 | Ned Garver Club | Early access to episodes Live postseason game commentaries (2 per year) |
| $15 | Roger Angell Club | Email question priority on podcast Free access to Sports Mogul games One personalized Cameo-style message per year (new) |
| $30 | Rich Hill Club | Ad-Free Fangraphs membership Individual response to email questions Thank-you tweet (new) |
| $50 | Shohei Ohtani Club | Signed copy of The Only Rule Is It Has to Work or The MVP Machine (new) Second personalized Cameo-style message per year (new) Discount on FanGraphs merchandise (new) |
| $100 | Mike Trout Club | Guest appearance on episode |
